Sell your cards and collections
We buy Magic: The Gathering, Riftbound and more — one card or a whole collection. Bring it to either shop and we'll do the sorting, pricing and evaluating while you wait, and pay you by PayPal or Venmo, or in store credit. Two stores: Stevenson (Pikesville), Maryland and Lemoyne, Pennsylvania.
Our buy rates
Pokemon, Lorcana, One Piece, sealed product and the rest are quoted to the current market — bring it in or call for a number.
The rates above are our standard for Magic and Riftbound singles, based on current market value. Common cards under $1 are bought as bulk rather than priced one by one — see bulk pricing below. Everything else — other games, sealed product, and anything unusually hot or soft in the market — we quote in person against the day's prices, so rates are always subject to market conditions. A valid photo ID is required for every buy, and we may take a photo of it.
Bulk pricing (Magic & Riftbound only)
Common cards worth under $1 aren't priced one by one — they're bought as bulk at $5 per 1,000 cards, for Magic and Riftbound only. Sort foils from non-foils and pull anything you think beats a dollar, and you'll get the most for the box.
How it works
You don't have to price anything or know what's valuable — we handle the pricing and evaluating. A few quick things on your end make it go faster:
- Sort foils from non-foils. Keeping foils separate from regular cards speeds up evaluating and gets you paid sooner.
- Take cards out of sleeves, toploaders and binders. Loose cards are far quicker to go through — leave only genuinely high-value cards protected.
- Photo ID required. A valid government photo ID is required for any buy, no exceptions, and we may take a photo of it. It protects everyone against stolen and counterfeit cards and keeps the hobby honest.
- Small stacks on the spot; big collections, call ahead. A deck box we can handle while you wait. For a full collection, call the shop first so we can set aside the time to do it right.
- PayPal, Venmo or store credit. Store credit is worth more — 70% versus 60% on Magic and Riftbound singles — and it spends on anything in the shop.
Where to bring it
Both shops buy. Our Stevenson, Maryland store is minutes from Pikesville, Owings Mills and Baltimore; our Lemoyne, Pennsylvania store is a few minutes from Camp Hill, Mechanicsburg and Harrisburg. Bring your collection to whichever is closer — call ahead for anything larger than a deck box.
Not near either shop? You can mail your cards in to sell. Email us at info@stevensongames.com first and we'll send our mailing address and how the mail-in buy works.
Selling your cards — common questions
How much do you pay for cards?
Magic: The Gathering and Riftbound singles are bought at 60% of current market value by PayPal or Venmo, or 70% in store credit. Other games, sealed product and bulk are quoted in person against the day's market prices.
Do you buy whole collections?
Yes — anything from a single card to a full collection. We do the sorting, pricing and evaluating for you. For anything larger than a deck box, call the shop first so we can set aside the time.
Do I need ID to sell cards?
Yes. A valid government photo ID is required for every buy, no exceptions, and we may take a photo of it. It protects everyone against stolen and counterfeit cards.
How do you pay us out?
By PayPal or Venmo, or in store credit. Store credit is worth more — 70% versus 60% on Magic and Riftbound singles — and it spends on anything in the shop.
Which stores buy collections?
Both. Bring your cards to our Stevenson (Pikesville), Maryland store or our Lemoyne, Pennsylvania store — whichever is closer.
Can I mail my cards in to sell?
Yes. Email us at info@stevensongames.com and we'll send our mailing address and walk you through it — you ship the cards, we evaluate them and send an offer, and you're paid by PayPal or Venmo.
Ready to sell?
Bring it to either shop, or send us a list first and we'll ballpark it. Either way, you get paid by PayPal or Venmo, or store credit, the same day.
Stevenson, MD 410-504-8169·Lemoyne, PA 717-376-3633